Dems: Study Shows Voter ID Law Jeopardizes Minority Vote

Survey of April primary voters shows more minorities, poor, elderly lack proper IDs.

Democratic state senators released a report Wednesday that drew on surveys from the April primary election to demonstrate a disproportionate number of poor, elderly and minority voters lack proper voter ID.

While the courts decide whether to issue an injunction against the law that requires citizens to produce a valid form of photo identification to vote, two lawmakers shared a report emphasizing why the law should be overturned.

State Sens. Vincent Hughes (D-7) and Anthony Hardy Williams (D-8) led a conference call with reporters Wednesday to discuss a Voter ID report compiled by the Center for Social Policy Studies at Swarthmore College.

"This confirms what we've been saying all along about this law, which is a failed law. At best, it should be thrown out. And worst, it needs to be" pushed back until after the election, Hughes said.

During the April 24 primary election, Dr. Keith W. Reeves, an associate professor of political science at Swarthmore and director of the Center for Social Policy Studies, surveyed random Philadelphia voters in real-time in 13 wards throughout the city.

According to a news release, "The survey was designed to determine to whether people of color, economically struggling and, or, seniors would be adversely impacted by (the Voter ID Law)... Because primary voters tend to be frequent voters, this served to investigate whether otherwise eligible voters would be disenfranchised by (the law)."

The study found:

  • 59 percent of survey respondents reported being asked for an ID
  • 4 percent did not possess any required photo ID and all were people of color
  • 59 percent reported possessing a driver’s license
  • In those surveyed over age 60, approximately half did not possess a driver’s license

Other facts to consider involved those surveyed. Forty-nine percent self-identified as African American and 33 percent identified themselves as white. While that may reflection Philadelphia demographics, U.S. Census data indicates African Americans reflect only 11.3 percent of Pennsylvania's population and whites are 83.8 percent—not a representative selection.

Additionally, while the election was framed as a "test run" and poll workers were instructed to ask for IDs, citizens were not required to show ID. Additionally, essentially zero marketing or community outreach occurred before the primary.

As the Nov. 6 election nears, the Department of State and the Pennsylvania Department of Education works to alert voters of the law and get them IDs.

PennDOT announced Tuesday it no longer requires citizens to provide proof of residency to get free IDs. Additionally, PennDOT centers will be open later on Thursdays to accommodate demand.

The senators, however, said those facts indicate how behind Pennsylvania is in issuing IDs.

Amend September 28, 2012 at 01:45 PM
Calling people stupid because they don't possess the proper ID to vote demonstrates your bias and which side of the aisle you sit on.
sherry September 28, 2012 at 01:48 PM
Agree with Keith on this: "There is nothing wrong with proving you are who you say you are when you vote. If you don't have a photo ID, go get one. " I am amazed at the many months this has gone on...by now EVERYONE should have an ID regardless if its for voting or not. Just do it...stop procrastinating. How many months do you really need to get one? GO TODAY. PLEASE.
PhilM September 28, 2012 at 02:36 PM
"PennDOT announced Tuesday it no longer requires citizens to provide proof of residency ..." What a waste of time and resources! The whole POINT to having an ID is to prove you meet the basic requirement to vote, of which the primary one IS "residency"!
Pat Shane September 28, 2012 at 07:06 PM
There is nothing wrong with requiring an ID to vote. HOWEVER There IS something wrong with implementing this new law 9 months before a presidential election. If voter fraud was so rampant in the last election, why didn't the GOP rush to pass this law immediately after the 2008 election? Wait until the 2016 election to impose this, that way it will give people 4 years to get their act together, and THEN you can give them the 'you have no excuse' treatment. Watch the video and sign the petition to end Voter Suppression. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L9TjVsQa57c
Agnes September 28, 2012 at 11:22 PM
If sincere, the new voter id law should be executed through the same goverment offices that now handle the voter registration process, not motor vehicle licensing centers. Also, it should only apply to new registrations, grandfathering out existing registered voters.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »